Fence comparison
Upfront price, lifespan, maintenance and the real cost per year, side by side.
Get a free quoteUpdated 1 November 2026
The short answer
Treated pine is the cheapest fence to put up. Colorbond costs a little more upfront but lasts about twice as long and needs no maintenance, so it's usually the cheapest over time. Hardwood sits in between on lifespan and costs the most to keep looking good.
| Colorbond 1.8 m | Treated pine paling | Hardwood | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical installed price | About $135/m | About $115/m | About $135/m |
| How long it lasts | 30+ years | 10 to 15 years | 20 to 25 years |
| Maintenance | None needed, a hose down now and then | Oil or paint every 3 to 5 years | Oil every 3 to 5 years to keep the colour, optional |
| Privacy | Full | Small gaps (full with lapped and capped) | Full, depending on style |
| Fire | Non-combustible steel | Combustible | Combustible |
| Repairs | Dented sheets are replaced | Single palings are cheap to swap | Single boards can be swapped |
| Rough cost per metre per year | About $5 | About $15 to $17 | About $13 if oiled, about $6 if left to weather |
How we worked out cost per year: typical installed price divided by the middle of the lifespan range, plus oiling or painting at about $30 per metre every 4 years for timber. It's a rule of thumb, not a quote. Prices include GST.
Compare styles and heights in our timber and Colorbond explorers, try the instant fence cost calculator, or send us photos for a written estimate.
Get a free quoteSources: whatsthedamage.com.au Colorbond vs timber fence cost (verified November 2026); Lysaght 10 year fencing warranty; our Melbourne fence price index. General information only.
Good to know
Upfront, a treated pine paling fence is usually a little cheaper, around $115 per metre installed in Melbourne against about $135 for 1.8 m Colorbond, including GST. Over the life of the fence Colorbond usually works out cheaper, because it lasts longer and doesn't need oiling or painting.
Published guides put Colorbond at 30 years or more. Lysaght, one of the main manufacturers, offers a 10 year fencing warranty on its products, subject to conditions.
Around 10 to 15 years with regular maintenance, according to published Melbourne guides. Posts and the bottom of palings usually go first, especially where they sit in damp ground.
Around 20 to 25 years for hardwood such as merbau or spotted gum. Oiling keeps the colour. Left unoiled, hardwood weathers to silver-grey but keeps its strength.
Colorbond and lapped and capped timber both give full privacy with no gaps. Standard paling has small gaps that open up a little as the timber dries.
Yes, if you both agree. In Victoria neighbours generally split the cost of a sufficient fence, and a neighbour who wants something more expensive usually pays the difference.
Ready when you are
Tell us about your fence and get a price for both options and send a few photos (or text them to 0494 785 366). We'll send you a written estimate, then confirm the final price before any work starts or any deposit is paid. No obligation to go ahead.