Fence replacement guide

Replacing a paling fence: repair or replace?

Signs your fence is due, when a repair will do, and what a new fence costs with removal.

Get a free quote
Free quote, no obligationLocal to Melbourne's eastOne point of contact

Before and after

From tired to new

Move across the photo to compare.

Old leaning paling fence with missing palings The same backyard with a new treated pine paling fence BeforeAfter

Illustrative example of a paling fence replacement.

Updated 1 November 2026

Signs your paling fence is due

Treated pine paling fences typically last 10 to 15 years, so a fence put up in the early 2010s or before is often near the end of its life.

Repair or replace?

What you seeUsually
A few split or missing palings, posts solidRepair. Swap the palings.
One or two posts rotten, rest of the fence soundRepair may work. Posts can be replaced or braced.
Several posts rotten, fence leaning along the runReplace. Patching won't last.
Fence is 15+ years old and patched beforeReplace. It's near the end of its life.
Old fibro or cement sheet fenceReplace, with licensed asbestos removal first.

Not sure? Send us a few photos of the fence, close-ups of the posts at ground level and one of the whole run. We'll tell you honestly whether it's worth patching or replacing.

What replacement costs

A new 1.8 m treated pine paling fence is typically $110 to $145 per metre installed, including GST. Taking down and disposing of an old timber fence is typically $16 to $47 per metre. For a typical 20 m backyard fence, that's about $2,200 to $2,900 for the new fence plus roughly $320 to $940 for removal, before splitting it with your neighbour. Gates and steep slopes are extra.

Indicative prices in Melbourne (November 2026). See the Melbourne fence price index or the instant fence cost calculator.

How replacing a fence works

  1. Talk to your neighbour. A dividing fence is usually a shared cost in Victoria. Agree on the style, height and which side faces whom.
  2. Get a written estimate. Send us your details and photos. We price the removal and the new fence together, so you both have one clear number.
  3. If you can't agree, a fencing notice is the formal next step. See who pays for a dividing fence.
  4. Old fence out, new fence in. The old fence is taken down and removed, new posts are concreted in, then rails, kickboard and palings go on. A standard run usually takes a day or two once materials are on site.

Replace with timber or Colorbond?

Most people replace a paling fence with another paling fence, or step up to lapped and capped for full privacy. Others switch to Colorbond for a fence that needs no maintenance. Our Colorbond vs timber comparison shows the cost per year of each.

Styles and finishes

What it can look like

Photos show styles and finishes as a guide. We quote your exact job from your details and photos.

Good to know

Common questions

How do I know if my paling fence needs replacing?

The main signs are a fence that leans or moves when you push it, posts that are soft or rotten at ground level, rails that have split or pulled away, and lots of loose, split or missing palings. If several posts along the run have gone, replacing is usually better value than repairing.

Can I just replace a few palings?

Yes, if the posts and rails are sound. Palings are cheap and quick to swap. New palings will look paler than the old grey ones at first, but they weather to match over time.

How much does it cost to replace a paling fence?

A new 1.8 m treated pine paling fence is typically $110 to $145 per metre installed, including GST. Removing and disposing of the old timber fence is typically $16 to $47 per metre. For a 20 m fence that's about $2,200 to $2,900 for the new fence plus roughly $320 to $940 for removal, usually split with your neighbour.

Do I have to pay for the whole fence?

Usually not. In Victoria, neighbours generally share the cost of a dividing fence. Talk to your neighbour first. If you can't agree, a fencing notice is the formal next step.

What if my old fence is fibro?

Old fibro or cement sheet fences may contain asbestos. Don't cut, break or pressure-wash them. They need a licensed asbestos removalist, which is priced separately. Tell us when you ask for a quote and we'll factor it in.

Should I replace timber with timber or switch to Colorbond?

Both are common. Timber paling is cheaper upfront and keeps a natural look. Colorbond costs a little more but lasts around twice as long with no maintenance. See our Colorbond vs timber comparison, or ask us to price both.

How long does it take to replace a fence?

Once materials are on site, a standard backyard run usually takes a day or two, including taking the old fence down. Concrete footings need time to set before the palings go on, and weather can shift things.

Ready when you are

Get your free quote

Tell us about your fence and send photos of the old fence and send a few photos (or text them to 0494 785 366). We'll send you a written estimate, then confirm the final price before any work starts or any deposit is paid. No obligation to go ahead.

Free fencing quote
Takes about a minute. Photos help us price faster.
Quicker? Text photos of your fence to 0494 785 366

Paling fence guides

More on paling fences